Back to Jobs

Insurance Call Center Supervisor I

Proctor Loan Protector
Solon, OH
Insurance Call Center Supervisor I Location Solon, OH : Built on meritocracy, our unique company culture rewards self-starters and those who are committed to doing what is best for our customers. Job Title: Call Center Supervisor I FLSA Status: Non-Exempt Department: Call Center Reports to : Call Center Director Location: Proctor - 166 Who are we? What do we do? Company Overview: Proctor Loan Protector provides comprehensive insurance products and service solutions for financial institutions. While weaving compliance throughout all our applications and technologies, Proctor Loan Protector operates as an extension of our clients, where partnership meets innovation. What's the culture like at Proctor Loan Protector? At Proctor Loan Protector, we are committed to fostering a workplace that values diversity and personal growth. As we continue to grow and expand, this allows us to offer career paths and opportunities. We are dedicated to ensuring that all our teammates feel valued and work in a fun and rewarding work environment. What can I expect from working at Proctor Loan Protector?
  • Fun work environment with a variety of work
  • Being part of a team
  • Career growth
  • Ability to highlight your skills
  • Feel valued
  • Great benefits, pay and culture
Tell me more about this role, what would I be doing? Summary: The Call Center Supervisor I is responsible for organizing, directing the day-to-day activities related to the operation of the Call Center. Also, for managing, training, and guiding call center agents in performing their duties. Provides support, reports and resolves problems and complaints. Monitors agents and contact center performance and analyzes reports. Responsible for having a practical mind to solve problems on the spot, collaborated with an ability to see the “big picture” and make improvements. Focus on goals to increase customer satisfaction and to ensure our agents meet their weekly, monthly and quarterly quotas. Essential Duties and Functions: include the following. Other duties may be assigned.
  • Supervises plans and manages functions related to the call center. Oversees and directs the day-to-day activities of the call center agents.
  • Monitoring team performance to ensure that the call center goals are met and supporting call center quality and training efforts.
  • Acts as a source of information and answers agents questions, assigns tasks, follows up and gives instructions as necessary.
  • Review statistical reports with management/agents to identify trends and assess performance.
  • Identify call center improvement opportunities to increase effectiveness and efficiency.
  • Identifying operational issues and suggesting possible improvements.
  • Assist in the overall performance standards by answering incoming calls, handling escalated calls, and conducting outgoing calls as needed to achieve goals.
  • Devise ways to optimize procedures and keep staff motivated.
  • Measure performance with key metrics such as call abandonment, average speed of answer and average talk time.
  • Monitoring and evaluating agent performance, providing learning or coaching opportunities, and taking corrective action, if necessary.
  • Working with other supervisors and management team members to support agents and maximize customer satisfaction.
  • Assists with QA monitoring, feedback, coaching
  • Anticipate escalation and take over call when needed.
  • Pursues a course of personal, professional development.
Competencies:
  • Results-driven - the ability to manage multiple queues to meet client expectations regarding average speed of answer; abandonment rate, and quality goals.
  • Customer/Client Focus - the tendency to strive to exceed customer expectations. Effectively elicit first-hand customer information and use it to resolve their queries.
  • Problem Solving - the ability to solve problems and understand complex and unfamiliar information. Readily learn and apply new information and skills on the job.
  • Planning/organizing—the individual prioritizes and plans work activities and uses time efficiently.
  • Interpersonal skills—the individual maintains confidentiality, remains open to others' ideas and exhibits willingness to try new things.
  • Oral communication—the individual speaks clearly and persuasively in positive or negative situations and demonstrates group presentation skills.
  • Written communication—the individual edits work for spelling and grammar, presents numerical data effectively and is able to read and interpret written information.
  • Adaptability—the individual adapts to changes in the work environment, manages competing demands and is able to deal with frequent change, delays or unexpected events.
  • Leadership - the individual manages work groups, works to develops others, build and maintain relationships, can effectively set vision and strategy and manage change.
  • Safety and security—the individual observes safety and security procedures and uses equipment and materials properly.
Qualifications: To perform this job successfully, an individual must be able to perform each essential duty satisfactorily. Reasonable accommodations may be made to enable qualified individuals with disabilities to perform the essential functions: Required:
  • High School Diploma/GED
  • Proficient with MS Office
  • Ability to maintain a high level of confidentiality
  • Advanced conflict resolution skills required
  • Outgoing, energetic personality; people person
  • Must be detail and results oriented
Preferred
  • College degree
  • 3+ years' experience in a call center environment
  • Excellent interpersonal communication skills
  • Ability to react and adapt to changes and priorities
  • Flexibility with work schedule
  • Ability to work overtime as necessary to meet goals
Physical Requirements Necessary on a Regular Basis:
  • Repetitive motion. Manual dexterity, arm and upper body range of motion sufficient for use of a keyboard, mouse and telephone 7-8 hours per day.
  • Speech and hearing sufficient for in-person and telephone communication 7-8 hours per day.
  • Vision sufficient for use of a computer monitor.
  • Sedentary position. Ability to sit at a desk 7-8 hours per day.
  • Worker not substantially exposed to adverse environmental conditions
Pay Ranges: Any posted pay range considers a wide range of compensation factors, including skills, experience, work location and more. We offer competitive pay while still allowing for compensation growth within the position and company. This is not meant to be an all-inclusive statement of the duties of the position listed above. Other appropriate duties may be required from time to time. EEO Statement: Proctor Loan Protector is an Equal Opportunity and Affirmative Action Employer. All qualified applicants will receive consideration for employment without regard to race, color, ethnicity, religion, sex, national origin, gender identification or sexual orientation, disability, protected veteran status or any other classification protected under law. We are an Equal Opportunity Employer. We take pride in the diversity of our team and seek diversity in our applicants.
Posted 2025-09-29

Recommended Jobs

Assistant Property Manager

Clear Investment Group
Columbus, OH

Job Title: Assistant Property Manager Location : Columbus, OH Job Type: Full Time, On-site   Compensation and Benefits   ~$50k-$60k + commensurate with experience   ~​Health Insurance  …

View Details
Posted 2025-08-18

Chic-fil-a Supervisor Cleveland State University

Aramark
Cleveland, OH

The Food Retail and Brand Location Supervisor is responsible for the supervision, training, and management of the food service operation. Ensure that appropriate quantities of food are prepared and s…

View Details
Posted 2025-09-29

Retail Assistant Store Manager- Kenwood Towne Centre

Lovisa
Cincinnati, OH

Assistant Store Manager Position Summary: We are seeking a dynamic Assistant Store Manager to help lead our retail team in delivering exceptional customer experiences while supporting daily operation…

View Details
Posted 2025-09-29

Production Associate - Route Preparation

Cintas Corporation
Vandalia, OH

Requisition Number: 207576  Job Description Cintas is seeking a Production Associate – Route Preparation to support the Rental Division. The Production Associate is responsible for accurately c…

View Details
Posted 2025-09-02

Supply Chain Operations Specialist I

CEVALogistics
East Liberty, OH

CEVA Logistics provides global supply chain solutions to connect people, products, and providers all around the world. Present in 170+ countries and with more than 110,000 employees spread over 1,500…

View Details
Posted 2025-09-30

Tool Maker Tool Maintenance Second Shift

Feintool Cincinnati, Inc.
Cincinnati, OH

Job Description Job Description * Operates all manual tool room equipment * Maintains tool maintenance journal (records) on tooling * Maintains and optimizes production tooling * Maintains i…

View Details
Posted 2025-09-26

Sr. Accountant

Avery Dennison
Mentor, OH

Avery Dennison Corporation (NYSE: AVY) is a global materials science and digital identification solutions company. We are Making Possible™ products and solutions that help advance the industries …

View Details
Posted 2025-09-23

Product Demonstrator - Inside Costco - Great Weekly Pay!

Zipfizz Corporation
Centerville, OH

&##128640; Join the Zipfizz Team as a Brand Promoter! Are you ready to take your energy and career to the next level? Zipfizz, the ultimate vitamin, energy, and hydration drink, is looking for enthu…

View Details
Posted 2025-09-02

What People Say about Their Experience

The Tandana Foundation
Spring Valley, OH

  "Tandana is to unite together, be together, struggle together. This is what you have done and what you are doing.  Tandana is not a sleeping word or a dead word.  It is a living word." -- Mati…

View Details
Posted 2025-08-06

Strategic Scheduling Specialist

FlightSafety International
Columbus, OH

About FlightSafety International FlightSafety International is the world’s premier professional aviation training company and supplier of flight simulators, visual systems and displays to commerci…

View Details
Posted 2025-09-23